Skip to content
Free Hydra LG humidifier with traditional cabinets over $2,500, through November 30
Free Hydra LG with traditional cabinets $2,500+, to Nov 30

Humidor Supreme vs Prestige Electric Humidors: Which Should You Buy?

Humidor Supreme vs Prestige: CubanVault guide

Choose Humidor Supreme for the most cigars per dollar and proven compressor cooling: the 9000 holds up to 4,500 cigars for about $0.79 a cigar. Choose Prestige if your room gets cold as well as warm (Prestige cabinets heat as well as cool, 41–71°F), or if you want furniture-style finishes and drawer shelves. For two climates, both brands make a dual-zone model: the Humidor Supreme 9200 (3,700–6,800 cigars) and the Prestige Reagan (up to 4,000). We sell both, and below is the honest comparison.

Side by side

Model Capacity Zones Climate control Size (W × D × H) Price
Humidor Supreme 9100 1,000–1,600 1 Compressor cooling + humidification 24 ¼" × 22 ¾" × 49 ⅜" $2,900
Humidor Supreme 9000 2,600–4,500 1 Compressor cooling + humidification 22 ⅜" × 27" × 75 ⅝" $3,549
Humidor Supreme 9200 3,700–6,800 2 Two compressors, two controllers 38 ¾" × 26 ¾" × 70 ⅞" $6,895
Prestige Redford Lite / Redford Up to 1,250 1 Cooling + heating 41–71°F; humidity 56–78% 25" × 24" × 52" / 26" × 26" × 52 ¾" $3,270 / $3,470
Prestige Remington Lite / Remington Up to 2,000 1 Cooling + heating 41–71°F; humidity 56–78% 25" × 24" × 72" / 26" × 26" × 74 ½" $4,190 / $4,500
Prestige Reagan Up to 4,000 2 Cooling + heating; dual zone 53" × 26" × 74 ½" $6,490

Prices are ours as of October 2026. Humidor Supreme quotes a range: the low figure is for cigars stored in boxes, the high figure for loose cigars. Prestige quotes a single "up to" figure.

Value: price per cigar

Chart of price per cigar for Humidor Supreme 9100, 9000, 9200 and Prestige Redford, Remington, Reagan electric humidors
On maximum rated capacity, the Humidor Supreme 9000 and 9200 are the best value per cigar.

Even using Humidor Supreme's lower "in boxes" figures, the 9000 (2,600 cigars, $1.37 each) beats every Prestige model on price per cigar. Prestige makes more sense when you value heating, drawer shelving or a furniture finish over raw capacity.

Where each brand wins

Humidor Supreme wins on

  • Capacity per dollar and per square foot: the 9000 holds up to 4,500 cigars in a footprint under 23 inches wide.
  • Compressor cooling: strong cooling that holds a set point in warm rooms; the 9200 has two compressors, one per zone.
  • Box storage: roll-out shelves sized for full boxes, plus drawers for singles.

Prestige wins on

  • Heating as well as cooling: useful in a cold garage, basement or cabin, where a cooling-only unit lets cigars get too cold.
  • Furniture finishes: dark cherry with embossed panels and crown molding, or simpler black oak "Lite" versions.
  • Drawer shelving with dividers and a de-mist glass door that stays clear.
  • Lower-height options: the Redford is about 52 inches tall, sideboard height.

Our picks

If you… Choose
Want the most cigars for the money Humidor Supreme 9000
Keep about 1,000 cigars in a warm room Humidor Supreme 9100
Keep cigars in a room that gets cold in winter Prestige Redford Lite or Remington Lite
Want two climates (aging + smoking) and maximum capacity Humidor Supreme 9200
Want two climates in a traditional furniture look Prestige Reagan

Before you buy either

  • Measure the route: doorways, stairs and turns. Both brands ship by freight on a pallet.
  • Plan the setting: most collectors run 65–70% humidity at 65–70°F (ideal humidity and temperature).
  • Use distilled water in the reservoir, and let the cabinet stand upright for a day before switching it on.
  • Size up: buy for about twice your current collection (how many cigars fit in a humidor).

More comparisons: Humidor Supreme 9100 vs 9000 vs 9200, the best electric humidors for large collections (including Raching), and wineador vs humidor vs electric humidor.

Not sure which size or type? The Humidor Finder suggests three humidors from how many cigars you keep and where it will go.

Buying one from us? The Humidor Supreme 9000, 9100 and 9200 come with our 30-Day Humidity Promise: a fit check before it ships, a setup call after delivery, and humidity checks at Day 14 and Day 30.

Comparing models? See all electric cigar humidors side by side, from 1,000 to 6,800 cigars, with free freight and sizing help by phone.

Humidor Supreme vs Prestige FAQ

Which is better, Humidor Supreme or Prestige?

Humidor Supreme gives more capacity per dollar with compressor cooling; Prestige adds heating and furniture styling. Choose by room temperature, capacity and looks.

Do Humidor Supreme electric humidors heat?

Humidor Supreme describes its electric cabinets as cooling and humidifying to your settings. If your room drops below your target temperature in winter, a Prestige model with heating is the safer choice.

Which dual-zone humidor holds the most?

The Humidor Supreme 9200, at 3,700–6,800 cigars across two independently controlled zones. The Prestige Reagan holds up to 4,000.

Are these in stock?

Prestige cabinets often sell from incoming containers, and Humidor Supreme ships from the distributor. Call (985) 531-8513 to confirm lead time before ordering.

Sources: Humidor Supreme and Prestige Import Group product specifications; CubanVault prices (October 2026). CubanVault is an authorized dealer of both brands.

Products in this guide

More buying guides