Skip to content
Free Hydra LG humidifier with traditional cabinets over $2,500, through November 30
Free Hydra LG with traditional cabinets $2,500+, to Nov 30

Best Cigar Bars in NYC: 9 Places You Can Still Smoke Indoors

Best cigar bars in NYC: CubanVault guide

New York City banned smoking in bars and restaurants in 2003, so a handful of places carry the city's cigar culture: cigar bars that were already operating and qualified for an exemption, plus tobacco shops with lounges. No new cigar bars can open under that exemption, which makes the survivors worth seeking out. This guide covers nine places in Manhattan, from Club Macanudo's dining rooms to the city's oldest cigar bar, with notes on what each does well and what lounge owners elsewhere can learn. Nobody paid to be included. Hours and entry rules change, so check before you go.

Best cigar bars in New York City by type: grandfathered cigar bars, shops with lounges and a private club
Three kinds of places you can still light up indoors in Manhattan.

Why NYC has so few cigar bars

New York's Smoke-Free Air Act and the state Clean Indoor Air Act prohibit smoking in almost all indoor workplaces, bars and restaurants. Cigar bars that existed before the 2003 bans and earn enough of their revenue from tobacco can register for an exemption, as can qualifying tobacco shops (NYC Health: Smoke-Free Air Act exemptions; NY State Clean Indoor Air Act). That's why every bar on this list is decades old.

Cigar bars

1. Club Macanudo, Upper East Side

On East 63rd Street between Park and Madison, Club Macanudo has offered dining and smoking since 1997. It's a series of grand rooms with sculpted ceilings, leather couches and low light, and it's open to the public despite the name; expect a dress code (Cigar Aficionado). Go for: dinner and a cigar at the same table.

2. The Carnegie Club, Midtown

Next to Carnegie Hall, a classic pre- and post-show cigar bar known for cocktails and regular live entertainment (Cigar Aficionado). Go for: a cigar and live music after a concert.

3. Hudson Bar & Books, West Village

Established in 1991, it's the city's oldest cigar bar, with an Old New York feel: mosaic floors, tin ceilings and not much elbow room (Cigar Aficionado). Go for: late nights; it's known for staying open late.

4. Merchants Cigar Bar, Upper East Side

At 1125 First Avenue, Merchants first opened in 1997 and reopened in December 2020 after a long renovation, with an AtmosAir air-purification system, a full bar with a strong Scotch list and a "dress to impress" code (Cigar Aficionado). Go for: Scotch and a steak-tartare-level menu.

5. Soho Cigar Bar, SoHo

At 32 Watts Street, an Art Deco-style bar with candle-lit tables, whiskey flights paired with cigars, a popular house cigar, and a ventilation system the owner says has double the required capacity (Cigar Aficionado). Go for: a relaxed, more affordable downtown night.

Tobacco shops with lounges

6. Barclay Rex

A long-running family tobacconist with a cozy lounge and humidified lockers (Cigar Aficionado). Go for: a quiet cigar with people who know tobacco.

7. Davidoff of Geneva, Madison Avenue

Davidoff's Madison Avenue boutique has a loft lounge above the store, generally for members, with entry at management's discretion (Cigar Aficionado). Go for: Davidoff's full range and limited releases.

8. Cigar Inn

Home of the first Cigar Aficionado-branded lounge, with wood and leather and a well-designed walk-in humidor (Cigar Aficionado). Go for: a wide selection and a comfortable lounge.

Private club

9. Grand Havana Room

Manhattan's best-known private cigar club, invitation-only, with lockers and skyline views (Cigar Aficionado). Go for: if you know a member.

What lounge owners can learn from New York

  • Air quality is the business. In a city where smoke laws are strict, the bars that last invest in serious air handling (Merchants' AtmosAir, Soho Cigar Bar's oversized ventilation). Size yours with our ventilation and smoke-eater guide.
  • Food and drink carry the margin. Club Macanudo, Merchants and Soho Cigar Bar pair cigars with full menus and whiskey programs.
  • Lockers and membership create regulars. Barclay Rex's humidified lockers and Grand Havana's membership show the model; see locker pricing and payback.
  • Check the law before you sign a lease. NYC shows how much a smoking exemption is worth. Our how to open a cigar lounge guide starts with this step.

Also in this series: Florida and Texas.

New in the series: the best cigar lounges in Atlanta, Las Vegas, Chicago and Arizona.

Planning your own cigar room? Tell us about your space and we will send a free Room Plan with two equipment options and delivered prices, or call (985) 531-8513.

Opening or upgrading a lounge? See our cigar lounge equipment, from commercial humidors to cigar lockers, or get a free room plan.

NYC cigar bar FAQ

Can you smoke cigars in bars in New York City?

Only in exempt places: cigar bars that existed before the 2003 bans and meet the tobacco-revenue rules, and qualifying tobacco shops. Ordinary bars and restaurants are smoke-free.

Can a new cigar bar open in NYC?

Not under the grandfathered cigar-bar exemption, which applies only to establishments operating before the bans. Check with the NYC Health Department for current rules.

Which NYC cigar bar is open to the public?

Club Macanudo, the Carnegie Club, Hudson Bar & Books, Merchants and Soho Cigar Bar are open to the public (with dress codes at some). Grand Havana Room is private.

Is this list sponsored?

No. Nobody paid to be included.

Sources: NYC Health; NY State Department of Health; Cigar Aficionado reviews and city guide. Details change; confirm hours, dress codes and entry rules with each venue.

Products in this guide

More buying guides